New At Apple Creek- Cooper Sharp

Iconic Pennsylvanian Cheese since 1893! Cooper Sharp is a Sharp White American Cheese. This cheese melts incredibly well and is delicious on Philly Cheesesteaks. This cheese is quickly becoming a popular item here at Apple Creek! Come try it out for yourself!

Stop by today to try our famous Amish Butter Cheese!

Employee Favorites

  • Yellow Amish Butter Cheese

  • Muenster

  • Horseradish Cheddar

  • Green Onion

  • Blueberry Cheddar

  • Mediterranean Sunset

  • Garlic Cheese

  • Hot Pepper

  • Desert Fire

  • Smoked Swiss

Our Mediterranean Cheddar has a blend of Italian herbs, spices, and sundried tomatoes! It tastes like a pizza!

Are you brave enough to try our spicy cheeses?

Try our customer favorite Desert Fire Cheese! It tastes good on practically anything!

Deli Cheeses

Traditional

  • Colby

  • Marble

  • American Yellow

  • White American

  • Yellow Amish Butter Cheese

  • White Amish Butter Cheese

  • Muenster

  • Mozzarella

  • Provolone

  • Colby Swiss Swirl

Cheddar

  • Cheddar

  • Sharp Cheddar

  • X-Sharp Cheddar

  • Mediterranean Sunset

  • Horseradish Cheddar

  • 2 Year Aged White Cheddar

  • Sharp White Cheddar

Specialty

  • Garden Vegetable

  • Green Onion

  • Bacon

  • Garlic Cheese

  • Horseradish American

  • Havarti

  • Havarti Dill

  • Blue Marble

  • Bruschetta Jack

  • Blueberry Cheddar

Swiss

  • Swiss Cuts

  • Guggisberg Baby Swiss

  • Lacey Baby Swiss

  • Aged Swiss

  • Swiss n Rye

Smoked

  • Smoked Swiss

  • Smoked Bacon

  • Smoked Provolone

  • Smoked Hot Pepper

  • Smoked Horseradish Cheddar

  • Smoked Green Onion

  • Smoked Gouda

  • Smoked Habanero Jalapeno

Hot Cheese

  • Hot Pepper

  • Pepper Jack

  • Habanero Cheddar

  • Muenster Jalapeno

  • Desert Fire

  • Mango Fire

  • Lightning Jack

  • Ghost Pepper

  • Scorpion Pepper

  • Carolina Reaper